Section 270A of Income Tax Act: Penalty For Under-reporting and Misreporting of Income

Section 270A of the Income Tax Act is a key provision that addresses penalties for under-reporting or misreporting income. This section was introduced to curb tax evasion. In this article, we will explore the scope of Section 270A, its applicability, its significance, and provide some illustrative examples.

---

What is Section 270A of the Income Tax Act?

Section 270A of the Income Tax Act was introduced through the Finance Act of 2017. It empowers the Assessing Officer (AO) to impose penalties on individuals who under-report or misreport their income in their Income Tax Returns (ITR).

---

What is Under-reporting of Income Under Section 270A?

Under-reporting of income occurs when an individual reports a lower income than what they actually earned. This can arise due to various reasons such as inadequate record-keeping or errors in income calculation.

The following situations are considered under-reporting of income under the Income Tax Act:

• Failure to disclose all income or parts of income in the income tax return or books of accounts.
  
  

• A return is filed, but the income assessed by the Income Tax Department is higher than the income reported in the return.
  
  

• No income tax return is filed, and the income assessed exceeds the basic exemption limit.
  
  

• If income declared under specific tax sections (like 115JB or 115JC) is less than what is computed by the Income Tax Department, it will be considered under-reported.
  
  

• A person will be considered to have under-reported their income if the income assessed or reassessed reduces the reported loss or converts a loss into income.
  
  

It's important to note that even minor errors or omissions in reporting income can attract penalties under Section 270A, underscoring the need for accurate and diligent income reporting.

What is Misreporting of Income Under Section 270A?

Misreporting of income refers to providing incorrect or misleading information regarding the type, source, or calculation of income. This can involve falsifying income details, making claims for unqualified deductions or exemptions, or providing inaccurate information about the sources of income.

Misreporting of income can occur in the following circumstances:

• Misclassifying the type or source of income, such as reporting business income as capital gains or vice versa.
  
  

• Providing inaccurate or incomplete information related to income measurement, such as underreporting costs or taxes.
  
  

• Claiming expenses without valid supporting documents or receipts.
  
  

• Failing to record certain receipts in the books of account, which affects the total income.
  
  

• Not disclosing international or certain domestic transactions, as mandated by the Income Tax Act.
  
  

---

Examples of Under-reporting and Misreporting of Income

Here are some typical examples that may be considered as under-reporting or misreporting of income under Section 270A:

• Understating Income: If a person earns Rs. 10,000 from various sources but reports only Rs. 8,000 in their tax return, they are under-reporting their income by Rs. 2,000.
  
  

• Failure to Report Investments: A person neglects to record the purchase of stocks worth Rs. 5,000 in their financial records, which is considered a failure to report investments.
  
  

• Unsubstantiated Expense Claims: A person claims Rs. 2,000 in business expenses without providing any receipts or invoices to support the claims.
  
  

• False Entries in Financial Records: A person reports an expense of Rs. 1,000, but no actual expenditure was incurred.
  
  

• Failure to Record Relevant Receipts: A person fails to disclose Rs. 1,500 in rental income received from a tenant, reducing their total income.
  
  

• Non-disclosure of International Transactions: A company fails to report a Rs. 20,000 payment received from a foreign client for services rendered, as required by tax laws governing international transactions.
  
  

Penalty Under Section 270A of the Income Tax Act

If the Assessing Officer determines that a taxpayer has underreported or misreported their income, a penalty under Section 270A of the Income Tax Act will be imposed. The penalty is as follows:

• For Under-reporting Income: A penalty of 50% of the tax due on the underreported income.
  
  

• For Misreporting Income: A penalty of 200% of the tax due on the misreported income.
  
  

It is crucial to understand that the penalty under Section 270A is in addition to the tax due on the underreported or misreported income.

The 200% penalty for misreporting income applies when the taxpayer intentionally provides false or misleading information. This indicates a more severe offense compared to unintentional mistakes or omissions.

---

Calculation Under Section 270A with Example

Let's consider an example to understand how the penalty is calculated:

Example:

Mr. Anil is a business owner with a total income of Rs. 15 lakh for the financial year 2022-23. However, during the assessment process, it was discovered that he had underreported his income by Rs. 5 lakh and misreported Rs. 2 lakh by claiming inadmissible expenses.

The penalty under Section 270A for Mr. Anil would be calculated as follows:

• Penalty for Under-reporting Income (Rs. 5 lakh):
  
  

• Penalty = 50% of the tax due on the underreported income.
  
  

• Assuming a tax rate of 30%, the penalty would be:
  0.5×(Rs.5,00,000×0.30)=Rs.75,0000.5 \times (Rs. 5,00,000 \times 0.30) = Rs. 75,0000.5×(Rs.5,00,000×0.30)=Rs.75,000
  
  

• Penalty for Misreporting Income (Rs. 2 lakh):
  
  

• Penalty = 200% of the tax due on the misreported income.
  
  

• Assuming a tax rate of 30%, the penalty would be:
  2×(Rs.2,00,000×0.30)=Rs.1,20,0002 \times (Rs. 2,00,000 \times 0.30) = Rs. 1,20,0002×(Rs.2,00,000×0.30)=Rs.1,20,000
  
  

Total Penalty:
The total penalty Mr. Anil would owe under Section 270A is:
Rs.75,000+Rs.1,20,000=Rs.1,95,000Rs. 75,000 + Rs. 1,20,000 = Rs. 1,95,000Rs.75,000+Rs.1,20,000=Rs.1,95,000

This is in addition to the tax owed on the underreported and misreported income.

Conclusion

Section 270A of the Income Tax Act plays a vital role in maintaining the integrity of the tax system by imposing strict penalties for underreporting and misreporting of income. Its primary objective is to deter tax evasion and ensure fairness in the tax system.

Taxpayers must take care to report their income accurately, maintain proper records, and seek professional guidance when necessary. While the penalties may appear harsh, they act as a deterrent against intentional or careless non-compliance. This highlights the importance of voluntary compliance and thorough tax planning, ensuring fairness and efficiency in the taxation process.